She lives in Toronto. In DePaul University denied his tenure, a decision for which Dershowitz lobbied. The foremost international authority on these archives, Birn conclusively demonstrates that Goldhagen systematically misrepresented their contents. You may have already requested this item. One was his assertion that, since all the Germans hated Jews, the SS and other directly involved in tormenting them did not need to take special measures to hide their cruelty from the German population-at-large, which fully supported such measures. One can easily flip the idea around so that “the Jim Crow system barely differed from pre-Holocaust Germany’s treatment of the Jews,” and while that might not make America precisely a nation of “closet racial psychopaths,” it certainly does not–and should not–provide any comfort for American readers.

Amazon Drive Cloud storage from Amazon. Start reading A Nation on Trial: Purporting to solve the mystery of the Nazi holocaust, Goldhagen maintains that ordinary Germans were driven by fanatical anti-Semitism to murder the Jews. Preview this item Preview this item. The E-mail message field is required. Trivia About A Nation on Trial Steve Hunt rated it it was amazing May 17,

A Nation on Trial: The Goldhagen Thesis and Historical Truth by Norman G. Finkelstein

Consider that he repeatedly contradicts it. An Inquest into Its Martyrdom Hardcover.

the goldhagen thesis and historical truth

Conor Fitzsimons rated it it was amazing Feb 25, Read more Read less. Had it not been for “Hitler’s moral authority,” Goldhagen observes, the “vast majority of Germans never would have contemplated” the genocide against the Jews Reply: Goldhagen claimed that the SS and SA guards took Jews on long, aimless, zigzag marches through the German countryside as the Allied armies poured across the borders for no other reason than to torment them.


Learn more about Amazon Prime.

A History of the Occupied Territories. Goldhagen never explains, however, why the Germans succumbed and why the Jews fell victim to this derangement.

A Nation on Trial

Birn is content to credit the “professional American marketing strategy” behind the book for its public success. Find more information about: It was the Nazis’ unprecedentedly “extreme and thoroughgoing In a complementary essay, Ruth Bettina Birn juxtaposes Goldhagen’s text against the German archives he consulted.

Shopbop Designer Fashion Brands. Now, in A Nation on Trial, two leading critics challenge Goldhagen’s findings and show that his work is not scholarship at all.

Follow the Author

Advanced Search Find a Library. Paperbackpages.

the goldhagen thesis and historical truth

Amazon Advertising Find, attract, and engage customers. Keerthi rated it really liked it Apr 13, Goldhagen’s recklessness seems to have inspired another work with a similar intent, “Ordinary Men”, znd Christopher Browning, It, too, is an attempt to tar every single German man, woman and child with the brush of racism and mass murder.

the goldhagen thesis and historical truth

Mike rated it it was amazing Jan 11, Finding libraries that hold this item Norman Finkelstein, son of a holocaust survivor, is a fierce and controversial critic of Israeli policy, especially toward Palestinians. Dec 27, Sarah rated it really liked it Shelves: For his views and suspected connections to anti-Zionist groups, Israel has denied Finkelstein entry and banned him from the country for a decade. Your list has reached the maximum number of items. Thus, he suggests that more histodical percent of the German people would have relished the occasion to torture and murder Jews.


Write a review Rate this item: War criminals — Psychology.

Vanessa Rosado rated it really liked it Apr 17, Consumed by a ferocious loathing of the Jews, the German people jumped at Hitler’s invitation to exterminate them. I do not recall I might be wrong, it’s been 10 years at least Goldhagen ever entertaining the quite reasonable explanation that the Germans were evacuating Jews from harm’s way, or just trying to keep them out of Allied hands.

Please re-enter recipient e-mail address es. Christopher rated it it was ok Jan 04, Citations are based on reference standards.